In a world chasing automation, MSME lending still needs human intelligence.
Here’s why algorithms alone can’t serve India’s most dynamic business segment—and what real credit officers know that tech doesn’t.
As someone who has worked in MSME credit for over a decade, I’ve seen firsthand how numbers tell part of the story—but never the full picture.
- A balance sheet may not show the entrepreneur’s adaptability.
- A credit score doesn’t capture a business’s local reputation.
- A cash flow issue today might be a result of seasonal cycles, not poor management.
This is where human judgment steps in. And it matters more than ever.
What Fintech Can’t Fully Solve (Yet):
While automation is essential, the MSME sector—especially in countries like India—still requires:
- Localized understanding of industries and clusters
- Customized structuring of loan products
- Sensitivity to the informal business landscape
- Clear financial education for borrowers
- On-ground risk assessment and long-term handholding
The Limitations of Algorithmic Lending
In today’s digital world, MSME lending is becoming increasingly automated. Fintech platforms, digital underwriting models, AI-based credit scoring systems—these are all revolutionary tools.
But they can’t yet:
- Walk through a small factory and see underutilized machinery
- Understand the seasonal cycles of a fruit export business
- Grasp the trust that a business has built in its community over decades
- Guide an entrepreneur on what type of loan is actually best for their situation
- Balance financial documents with on-ground realities and practical eligibility
This is where the role of an experienced credit officer or business advisor becomes indispensable.
What Real MSME Credit Evaluation Requires
When assessing an MSME loan proposal, it’s not just about verifying:
- Income Tax returns
- GST filings
- Credit reports
It’s also about asking:
- Is this business scalable?
- Is this entrepreneur financially literate?
- Will this debt burden boost or break their operations?
- Is the unit facing supply chain disruptions or policy bottlenecks?
I’ve reviewed cases where:
- A business with poor ITRs got approved because real revenue was routed informally—but bank transactions proved stability
- A unit was advised to go for a working capital limit instead of a term loan, saving it from unnecessary debt
- A loan under CGTMSE was structured to reduce collateral pressure and support expansion
- A woman entrepreneur lacked documentation but had strong business practices—and was supported through Mudra and PMEGP schemes
That insight didn’t come from a score. It came from listening, observing, and understanding.
The Risk of Over-Automation
The real risk in MSME lending today is not NPA (non-performing assets)—it’s misjudgment:
- Approving risky loans due to overreliance on tech metrics
- Rejecting promising borrowers because they don’t “fit the model”
- Missing out on long-term relationship building due to fast, one-size-fits-all underwriting
We must stop thinking of MSME borrowers as data points. They are human. They are ambitious. They are also vulnerable to misinformation and poor structuring.
The Case for Hybrid Lending: Technology + Human Advisory
I strongly believe in the power of technology. But in MSME credit, technology should support human decisions—not replace them.
- Tech helps reduce turn around time (Crucial for both banker and MSME)
- Algorithms flags high-risk patterns (Making easy for bankers to identify risk)
- Portals improve documentation and transparency (Minimizing the errors)
But:
- A credit officer can explain the why of a loan rejection .
- An advisor can help restructure a loan into a manageable package
- A banker can teach a client to become credit-ready for the future
That’s the real difference between lending and financial empowerment.
The Role of Advisors in the MSME Ecosystem
As a banker and an aspiring corporate business advisor, my goal is to:
- Help MSMEs become credit-worthy, not just credit-seeking
- Bridge the gap between business owners and the banking system
- Guide MSMEs in understanding documentation, schemes, structures, and suitability
- Offer professional handholding before, during, and after the loan process
This is especially critical as many MSMEs are unaware of:
- Credit rating impact
- Government subsidies and CGTMSE benefits
- The long-term effects of overleveraging
- How to negotiate or choose between funding options?
Winding up my thoughts:
The future of MSME finance lies in collaboration—not competition—between humans and machines. Credit scoring models may scale decisions, but relationships, context, and mentorship scale impact.
Let’s not reduce MSME finance to an equation. Let’s restore conversation, clarity, and customized strategy in the process.
If you’re a banker, fintech professional, or entrepreneur working with MSMEs—let’s connect. It’s time we build an ecosystem that supports real growth, not just approvals.
#MSMEFinance #CreditAdvisory #FinancialInclusion #BankingInnovation #HumanVsMachine #BusinessBanking #CreditOfficerPerspective #FintechAndFinance #CorporateBusinessAdvisor #IndiaToUAE #MSMEDevelopment #SangeetaSharma #BusinessAdvisory